The internal structure of MOSFET and IGBT differs significantly, which leads to variations in their application areas. MOSFETs are capable of handling large currents, often reaching the kiloampere range, but their voltage withstand capability is generally lower compared to IGBTs. On the other hand, IGBTs can manage high power levels with both high current and voltage, making them suitable for applications where high power is required.
IGBTs typically operate at frequencies up to 100kHz under hard-switching conditions, which is quite good for many applications. However, they fall short when compared to the high-frequency capabilities of MOSFETs, which can operate at hundreds of kHz, even up to MHz or higher, making them ideal for RF and high-frequency applications.
In terms of application, MOSFETs are commonly used in switching power supplies, ballasts, high-frequency induction heating, and communication power supplies due to their fast switching speeds. IGBTs, on the other hand, are widely used in welding machines, inverters, electroplating systems, and high-power induction heating equipment because of their ability to handle high power efficiently.
The performance of a Switch Mode Power Supply (SMPS) largely depends on the selection of power semiconductor devices, such as switching transistors and rectifiers. While there's no one-size-fits-all solution for choosing between IGBT and MOSFET, analyzing their performance in specific SMPS applications helps determine key parameters like switching losses in both hard-switching and soft-switching ZVS topologies.
Switching losses include conduction loss, turn-on loss, and turn-off loss, all of which are influenced by circuit and device characteristics. The recovery characteristics of the diode play a crucial role in determining conduction switching losses for MOSFETs and IGBTs, especially in hard-switching topologies.
Conduction loss refers to the energy lost while the device is in the on-state. In IGBTs, the presence of a tail current during turn-on affects the VCE voltage drop, leading to a quasi-saturation effect. This delay results in higher energy consumption during the turn-on phase, known as Eon loss. The Eon loss is measured as the time integral of the product of collector current and VCE over each cycle, and it is divided into Eon1 and Eon2 based on whether the loss includes diode recovery energy.
For hard-switching circuits, the gate drive voltage, impedance, and the recovery characteristics of the rectifier diode influence Eon loss. Choosing a diode with minimal Trr and QRR, along with soft recovery characteristics, helps reduce noise and voltage spikes. In contrast, MOSFET body diodes have slower recovery times, limiting the operating frequency in hard-switching applications.
IGBTs often come with matched diodes that provide optimal performance for their intended use. For example, ultrafast diodes with soft recovery are paired with high-frequency SMPS IGBTs, while slower diodes are used with motor drive IGBTs. Adjusting the gate drive source impedance can also help control Eon loss by influencing the rate of current rise (di/dt).
Turn-off losses, or Eoff, are another critical factor. IGBTs experience higher Eoff losses due to the tail current caused by minority carrier removal in the PNP BJT. MOSFETs, however, have lower Eoff losses because they do not exhibit this tail current. ZVS and ZCS topologies can further reduce these losses, though the benefits vary depending on the device type.
When selecting a power switch, factors such as circuit topology, operating frequency, ambient temperature, and physical size must be considered. There is no universal solution, and the best choice depends on the specific requirements of the application. MOSFETs excel in high-frequency, low-loss scenarios, while IGBTs are preferred for high-power, moderate-frequency applications. Ultimately, the decision should be made based on a thorough analysis of the system’s needs.
Servo Lifting Column,Mobile Column Lift,Lifting Column Actuator,Industrial Lifting Equipment
Kunshan Zeitech Mechanical & Electrical Technology Co., Ltd , https://www.zeithe.com